Books: Should 'The Blood of The Vampire' have just stayed in its grave?

Graphic by Gabriella Orta ‘28

By honor Quinn ‘27

Staff writer

All over my social media feed for weeks during the month of October, I saw video upon video all parroting some variation of the phrase, “Did you know Penguin Random House is republishing a bisexual, biracial vampire novel released the same year as “Dracula”?!” But they would say little else beyond this hook; little about the author Florence Marryat, from whom “The Blood of the Vampire” was only one out of the 70 novels she wrote during her lifetime. And little about the actual plot beyond the back cover copy. The quick rundown of the novel goes as follows: Harriet Brandt is a psychic vampire that “feed[s] off life force rather than blood.” At 21, after being raised in a convent in Jamaica, she moves to Europe and attempts to start a new life. She finds herself wrapped up in the lives of two English women, Margaret and Elinor, and here we see her psychic drainings begin to impact those around her including Margaret’s young child. And as the bodies begin the drop, the question arises of if Harriet’s journey will begin to follow the same trajectory of her more famous vampiric contemporaries.

I was immediately intrigued, morbidly curious even, of what was seemingly being pitched to me as the bisexual “Carmilla” by Sheridan Le Fanu. But it also elicited some hope. At a time when queer fiction is being attacked and more and more titles are falling under the subject of book bans, having one of the mainstream Big 5 publishers not only rerelease a “lost” transgressive queer text but to so loudly champion it as such in its marketing campaign is a bold move. It shows that they understand that there is, without a doubt, an audience for these books and that they should be well known and appreciated. The fact that it was a queer vampire novel of all things was just the cherry on top, especially as a fall release. However, this is not to say that Marryat’s 1897 is a paragon of perfection, especially for the modern day reader, but that doesn’t mean that we can’t still get something out of it.

 Visiting Assistant Professor of English Caitlin Mahaffy spoke with Mount Holyoke News over email to share her professional familiarity with the text and her thoughts on what our campus community might make of it.

“I encountered this text years ago as a third-year PhD student. I am both surprised and unsurprised that it is being [re]published … There has been … a resurgence of interest in vampires in recent years. In the last three years alone, I know of two adaptations of ‘Carmilla’ into modern novels. There are many ‘Dracula’ retellings in books, on stage, and on the screen. The ‘Interview with a Vampire’ TV series is a hit. These are just a few examples! So I imagine publishers thought it would be worthwhile to reintroduce an old story that features a vampire to the public,” Mahaffy said.

“Here is why I feel slightly surprised: If I recall correctly, in Marryat’s short story, the vampire is biracial and her race — like her gender — is portrayed as though it is part of what makes her monstrous … I was reading tonight that certain readers feel that the text is critiquing the tendency of some of the characters to view Harriet (the main character) as monstrous due to her gender, race, sexuality, or all three. But I remember feeling uncomfortable as I read the story because I felt these issues were not handled as sensitively within the text as they could have been. My sense is that the general public may find the text uncomfortable to read for that reason. The same will likely be true of many Mount Holyoke students. Though, having said that, I could also see MHC students writing brilliant critiques of the story — highlighting what exactly makes it problematic and how some of the prejudices it presents (and arguably endorses) continue to do harm today,” Mahaffy wrote,

Mahaffy is far from alone in these thoughts. The Mary Sue, in their review of the new edition, wrote that “The marketing for this re-release tells readers they are getting representation, and what the novel actually offers is subtext, anxiety and a good deal of ugliness.”

Should one of Marryat’s most notable works have just stayed in the grave? Perhaps again, only time can tell. 

Jillian Stammely '28 contributed fact-checking.