Graphic by Brianna Stockwell ’28
By Sachiko Arai ’29
Managing Editor of Web
“Don’t drink anything offered. Don’t go by yourself. Don’t wear revealing clothes.”
We've heard these phrases so often that we almost forget to question them. They trick women into thinking that at the end of the day, they are the ones to blame, even if they had never said “yes” to begin with.
Mount Holyoke College has offered me an environment I never knew was possible.
Here, I can almost forget the moments in high school when I heard my male classmates snickering during sex education class, or when I received a text from a male student I had trusted demanding to know the color of my underwear.
I almost forgot those moments, until I learned about the Cornell University case.
In 2024, seven Cornell students who were part of the Chi Phi fraternity allegedly gang-raped a 20-year-old woman.
Now that the story has been exposed, it has caused widespread shock and is being referred to as the “Cornell 7.” This incident sparked outrage over the “Cornell 50,” referring to the 50 other fraternity members who allegedly knew about the events that night and failed to speak out.
An interview that The Cutconducted with CatherineSanderson, a professor of social psychology at Amherst College, examined why so many people remained silent.
According to Sanderson, it is likely that many psychological factors have led to this outcome. Students may have evaded their duty of responsibility to report sexual assault because of the sense that there are so many others who could potentially handle it.
Additionally, she notes that fear of ostracism and retaliation from reporting members of your group may also encourage this silence.
A former fraternity member at Chi Phi recounted his experience:
“Fraternities are basically cults. Because hazing teaches people to break down their boundaries, to be people pleasers, to humiliate others. When you have a whole group of people doing that, it normalizes suffering and pain, so then when someone else suffers, like say they get raped, it’s like, oh, it’s no big deal. Like, tough it out, you know?”
Therefore, it was not surprising that after the lawsuit of Jane Doe, the university has decided to ban parties at fraternity houses for the rest of the academic year.
According to The New York Times, “a protest in support of Jane Doe at the Ithaca Commons opened on Tuesday afternoon with a round of applause for the ban.”
However, many are critical of the decision.
The decision seems to suggest that as long as we ban fraternities, the case would be resolved.
However, is that really so? Even if we were to ban such fraternities, there is a possibility that rape culture would still be continued through the creation of new groups.
In an interview with The New York Times, a student at Cornell has even raised the possibility that “younger students might flock … for off-campus parties that are outside of the university’s purview.”
This could be just as harmful, as misogynistic social behaviors in off-campus spaces could be even more difficult to monitor. It could also lead to the expansion of male-dominated spaces where problematic attitudes, such as those expressed through “locker room talk,” continue to go unchallenged.
Banning fraternities could be a possible prevention of sexual assault on campus grounds. However, it is highly unlikely that it will solve the root causes.
When looking up the Cornell case, I was able to discover powerful articles and movements initiated by women, both on and off Cornell campus grounds. In fact, even on the grounds of Wellesley College, another historically women’s college, protests have occurred in response to the case.
Women have always been raising their voices, loud and clear. Perhaps it’s time we question men's silence.
The media has rightfully condemned all the male students allegedly involved, as well as fraternity culture. Yet media coverage still doesn’t focus on why members of the Chi Phi fraternity were unable to speak out against sexual assault
The question of why men continue to perpetrate sexual violence has increasingly become a rhetorical one, asked repeatedly without a genuine effort to investigate its causes.
If we are serious about preventing sexual assault, we must move beyond asking women how they can protect themselves. Instead, we need to begin asking how communities can prevent sexual violence and harassment in the first place.
True change requires college campuses to continue sustaining inclusive and transparent discussions that all can join, including men.
Shutting down parties may be a good starting point, but if it results in shuttingdown further conversations, it is hardly a good ending point.
Zoe Brisbois ’30 contributed fact-checking.
